Skip to content
Pickfetti

Comparisons

Pickerify vs Pickfetti: Free Limits, Prices and How Many Comments Each Actually Reads

Pickerify and Pickfetti side by side: free limits, one-time pass prices, proof pages, platforms, and a measured test on the same 972-comment giveaway post (27 entries vs 666). Their own published terms, dated.

Last updated November 8, 2026 · 6 min read

Pickerify and Pickfetti look alike on paper: both pick a random winner from the public comments on an Instagram post with no login, both publish a random seed and an entry-list hash so the draw can be re-run, both sell one-time passes for big posts. This page puts them side by side on their own published terms, dated, and adds the one number neither tool's pricing page tells you: how many of the comments on the post actually make it into the draw. We measured that on the same post with both tools on 8 November 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Both are free up to 1,000 comments with no login, no account and unlimited draws.
  • Pickerify reads comments “for a set time” (about 20 seconds on a free draw, per its FAQ). On a 972-comment post its draw contained 27 entries. Pickfetti read the same post in full: 970 comments from 666 people.
  • Pickerify covers Facebook, YouTube and TikTok in one tool and its $4.99 pass reaches 15,000 comments. Pickfetti covers Instagram and YouTube; its $4.99 pass reaches 10,000, and Pro is $9 a month against $12.
  • Pickerify's results page shows a seed and a hash but not the number of entries. Pickfetti's proof page shows the entry count, the retrieved-versus-reported comment numbers, and why each excluded comment was excluded.
  • If every entrant having a chance matters to you, the entry count is the number to check, on any tool.

Side by side

Each tool's own published terms as of 8 November 2026. Both change their pages, so confirm before a big draw.

PickfettiPickerify
Free limitUp to 1,000 comments per post, unlimited draws, no account or cardUp to 1,000 comments per post, unlimited draws, no account or card
Comments read per drawEvery public comment and reply on the post“Each draw reads comments for a set time; paid plans read longer” (its FAQ: about 20 seconds free)
Entries in the draw, same 972-comment post666 people (970 comments)27 people
Entry count shown to the host and entrantsYes, with Instagram's reported count beside itNo
LoginNoneNone
PlatformsInstagram posts, carousels and Reels; YouTube videos and ShortsInstagram, Facebook Pages and public groups, YouTube, TikTok; pasted lists
RulesTag N different friends (pooled per person), keyword or hashtag, one entry per person, exclusions, ignore replies, date window, verify drawn winners follow the hostTag-a-friend minimum, keyword or hashtag, one entry per person, exclusions, entry window, replies on or off; no follow check
ProofPublic page with seed, entry-list hash, rules, entry count and exclusion reasons; winner card; CSV; labelled redrawsPublic page with seed and entry-list hash; verification file; winner image; labelled redraws
Winners per draw, free5 winners + 3 alternates10 winners + 5 backups
One-time pass$4.99 up to 10,000 · $9.99 up to 30,000 · $14.99 up to 100,000$4.99 up to 15,000 · $9.99 up to 50,000 · $14.99 up to 200,000
SubscriptionPro $9/month or $79/yearPro $12/month or $99/year
Comment exportEntries CSV with every draw; full export tool at igcomments.comExport and viewer included with a pass
CompanyCGHM Associates LLC, United StatesStelvy LLC, New Mexico, United States

The test

We picked a public Instagram giveaway post that Pickfetti had drawn on 5 November 2026: Instagram showed 972 comments, Pickfetti had read 970 of them, from 666 different accounts, including 10 replies. On 8 November we pasted the same link into Pickerify's free Instagram comment picker twice, with its default rules (one entry per person, replies counted, host excluded), and downloaded the entry list from each results page.

  • Draw one: 27 entries. Draw two: 27 entries, the same 27 names.
  • On the second run the comments request failed with a server error, the page still reported “Comments ready”, and the draw went ahead.
  • Six of seven names we spot-checked appear in Pickfetti's 666, so it was the same thread, cut short.
  • Neither results page states how many entries were in the draw. The seed and hash verify correctly: they prove a random pick was made from 27 people, not that 666 people had a chance.

None of this is hidden by Pickerify. Its how-it-works page says the reading stage has “a set reading time” and that paid plans read longer. The point of this guide is that the line matters more than the free limit next to it: a 1,000-comment free tier that reads for 20 seconds is, in practice, a draw among the first pages of comments.

When Pickerify is the better fit

  • Your giveaway is on Facebook or TikTok, or spans several platforms, and you want one tool for all of them.
  • Your post has between 10,001 and 15,000 comments and you want the $4.99 price point. (Check the entry count on the results page afterwards.)
  • You run Facebook group giveaways and are happy to paste entries as a list when the group is private.

When Pickfetti is the better fit

  • You want every comment on the post in the draw and a proof page that says how many there were.
  • Your caption says “must follow”: Pickfetti checks the drawn winners and alternates and lists the result; Pickerify can't check follows.
  • You want to see retrieved versus reported comment counts and the reason each comment was excluded, so an entrant who asks “why not me?” gets an answer.
  • You run several giveaways a month: Pro is $9 against $12.
  • You need a company invoice with your VAT or tax ID after paying.

To try it: paste your post link into Pickfetti. Free up to 1,000 comments, with the price for bigger posts shown before anything is read. The wider field is on the best free Instagram comment pickers page.

FAQ

Is Pickerify free?

Yes, for posts with up to 1,000 comments, with no login or account, according to its pricing page on 8 November 2026. Each free draw reads comments for about 20 seconds, so the draw may include only part of the thread.

Does Pickerify read all the comments?

Not necessarily. Its FAQ says each draw reads comments for a set time and paid plans read longer. In our test on a 972-comment post the free draw contained 27 entries.

Does Pickfetti read all the comments?

Yes. Pickfetti reads every public comment and reply on the post before drawing, shows the number read next to Instagram's reported count, and lists the entry count on the proof page. Deleted, hidden and spam-filtered comments are not public and no tool can read them.

Which is cheaper for a big giveaway?

Up to 10,000 comments both charge $4.99. From 10,001 to 15,000 Pickerify is $4.99 and Pickfetti is $9.99. For monthly use Pickfetti Pro is $9 against Pickerify's $12.

How can I check any picker's draw myself?

Open the results page and look for three things: the random seed, the entry-list hash, and the number of entries. If the number of entries is missing, download the entry list and count it against the comments on the post before you announce a winner.