Skip to content
Pickfetti

Fairness & trust

Log in With Instagram, or Paste a Public Link: Which Is Safe and Which Is Allowed?

Both can be safe: an official login happens on Meta’s own screen and grants a tool permissions on your account; a public link needs no password and never touches your account. What each can do, when the official API is the right choice, and how the result is proved.

Last updated November 18, 2026 · 6 min read

Both can be safe: logging in is safe when it happens on Meta’s own login screen and you grant limited permissions, and a public-link tool is safe because it never asks for your password or touches your account. Meta’s official API is the route Instagram provides for reading comments on accounts you manage; a public-link tool reads only what any logged-out visitor can already see, and either way you are the one responsible for running the giveaway by the rules.

What a login-based tool asks for, and what it can then do

Tools built on Meta’s official API send you to an Instagram or Facebook login screen. There you see the permissions the tool is asking for and approve them. The tool receives an access token, not your password.

  • Account type: the API works with professional accounts (Business or Creator), often linked to a Facebook Page. A personal account cannot be connected.
  • What it can read: posts and comments on the accounts you manage. It does not give a tool the comments on a post owned by an account you cannot log in to.
  • What it can do: depending on the permissions you approve, also reply to, hide or delete comments on your posts. Read the list before you approve it.
  • How to take it back: access lasts until you remove it in your Instagram or Facebook settings, under the apps and websites you have connected.

Red flag: a site that asks for your Instagram password on its own page. That is not Meta’s login, and your password should never be typed there. More on this in giveaway scams to avoid.

What a public-link tool reads, and what it cannot do

A public-link tool such as Pickfetti takes the link to a public post or Reel and reads the public comments, the same ones anyone sees without logging in. There is no password, no permission screen and nothing to revoke afterwards. Pickfetti gets those public comments through a third-party data provider; nothing runs on your account.

What it cannot do, stated plainly:

  • Read private accounts, or anything else behind a login.
  • Verify likes, saves or Story shares: Instagram does not publish those lists.
  • Read comments Instagram hides from everyone (spam-filtered, hidden words, restricted or deleted), which is why the number read can be lower than Instagram’s count. See why the comment count doesn’t match.
  • Post, comment, like, follow or send messages for you.

If the account is private, or you already have the entries, you can paste the comments as a list. Free up to 1,000 comments per post when Pickfetti reads them from the link, and free with no comment limit when you paste the comment list yourself.

What is allowed?

This is general information, not legal advice. What can be said factually:

  • Instagram’s Terms of Use say people may not collect information from the service in an automated way without Instagram’s permission. With a public-link tool you do not log in and nothing runs on your account: the service fetches the public comments.
  • The official API is the route Instagram provides for accessing the comments on accounts you manage.
  • Instagram’s Promotion Guidelines make the host responsible for running the promotion lawfully: official rules, eligibility, and a statement that the promotion is not sponsored by Instagram. That applies whichever tool you use. See Instagram’s promotion guidelines, explained.

When the official API really is the right choice

  • The post is on a private account you manage.
  • You need to reply to, hide or moderate comments at scale, not only read them.
  • Your company’s or your client’s policy requires Meta-approved integrations.
  • You are building a recurring, automated workflow on your own accounts.

For an ordinary giveaway on a public post, especially one you do not own (a collab giveaway, for example), a public link is usually the simpler route. The longer comparison is in no-login versus official-API pickers and the no-login picker guide.

How Pickfetti proves its result

  • A public proof page for every draw (pickfetti.com/d/…): winners, alternates, rules, the number of entries, the random seed and a hash of the full entry list. Anyone can re-run the draw from those and get the same winner, and a machine-readable copy sits at /d/{code}/verify.json.
  • Read versus reported: Pickfetti shows how many comments it read next to the number Instagram reports, so any gap is visible instead of hidden.
  • No password, anywhere: there is no field on the site where an Instagram password could be typed.

FAQ

Is a comment picker that only asks for the post link safe?

Yes, in the sense that it asks for no password and no permissions and cannot act on your account. It reads only the public comments on a public post.

Is logging in with Instagram to a giveaway tool dangerous?

No, if the login happens on Meta’s own screen and you check the permissions. The tool receives a token, not your password, and you can remove its access at any time.

Can a public-link tool verify likes or Story shares?

No. Instagram does not publish who liked a post or shared it to their Story, so no public-link tool can verify either.

Can I run the draw on another account’s post?

With a public link, yes, as long as the account is public. The official API only gives access to accounts you manage.

Does Meta’s API let a tool read someone else’s comments?

Not the comments on a post owned by an account you cannot log in to. The API returns comments for the accounts you manage.

How do my followers know the draw was fair?

Share the Pickfetti proof page: it publishes the seed, the rules and a hash of every entry, and anyone can re-run the draw.

What does Pickfetti cost?

Free up to 1,000 comments per post when Pickfetti reads them from the link, and free with no comment limit when you paste the comment list yourself.

Also in español and português.